Absolutely love purchasing holiday cookies from Rolling Sugar! We’ve made the “paint your own” cookies a tradition now and they never disappoint regardless of age. Aside from being super cute, these cookies are DELICIOUS!!! The cookie is soft but crisp and the icing isn’t too hard or painfully sweet. My only problem with them is I can’t stop eating them once I start!
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best cookies ever! The detail in the designs are unimaginable! I let Jen know we were looking for fire trucks, police cars, etc and what she came up with was so much better than I expected. And not to mention the taste of the cookies! Perfect softness to the cookie and sweetness of the icing!
Amazing cookies! I ordered the paint-your-own cookies and I couldn’t have been happier with them! The food-safe paints were a breeze to work with and worked just like regular watercolor paint. And the taste? Simply fantastic! The cookies had a good, thick layer of icing to prevent water from seeping through but weren’t sickly sweet. I will absolutely be back for more treats from Jen.
The online ordering process was easy. The cookies looked great and the kids enjoyed them. Pickup was easy and ready on time. I would definitely use them again.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
I've used Rolling Sugar Bakery many times now and plan to keep using them! I swear the cookies get cuter and cuter every time! I love the designs, Jenn has been flexible with my needs, and they come individually wrapped which is so nice!
Such darling cookies! I got donuts, paint an elf, pizza and hats with their names for my grandsons. Such a hit! The best decorating I’ve ever seen - even on cookie challenge shows on Food Network.
Recently ordered holiday cookies (small Elf on the Shelf gifts, the lumps of coal cookies, paint your own cookies, personalized Santa hats, and the mini boxes of small decorated Christmas cookies). They all looked so gorgeous and professional, as always, and these are hands-down my favorite sugar cookie. They are sweet, but not sickeningly sweet— just the right amount of sweet— and I LOVE the taste of her icing! I have ordered from this bakery on three other occasions (another Christmas, Thanksgiving, and I did a larger order for personalized cookies for a grad party for my son). I always get so many compliments from guests when I give cookies as favors, and it makes me feel like I’m giving my guests something special. I can’t wait to find my next excuse to order more! (And I hope to buy myself a few as I’m always buying for other people!) Highly recommend!
