Legendairy Cookies 'N Creamery Restaurant in Appleton

Owner not registered
Reviews
#72 From 259 in Appleton
9.1
116 Review
Ambience
9.1/10
Food
9.1/10
Interior
9.1/10
Prices
9.1/10
Service
9.1/10
More details
Price & Cuisine
$$$ Dessert
Establishment type
Restaurant
Reviews
116 reviews
Rating
Sorting
Date
Date From - Date To
avatar
Joe Lefevre
Source: google
10
8 months ago
Newer place in town. Fresh baked cookies and brownies made into ice cream actually custard sandwiches. We have some other Sundays or whatnot too, but their sandwiches are awesome. Personally I would suggest getting the combo brownie and cookie sandwich but everything I've tried here has been good. Prices are right in line with what you get. And you know it's fresh made because you watch them make it. Definitely give them a try if you're looking for a treat for the family.
avatar
Maria Terese
Source: google
10
7 months ago
Got some ice cream from their food truck and it was delicious! They had some great flavors to choose from, one dairy free option, and then their cookies. I really like the cookie sandwich idea where you create your own - choosing the cookies + ice cream.
The BEST ice cream sandwich I have ever had! Love that the cookie stays crunchy. Generous amount of ice cream! Server very friendly! Will definitely go back any time I can. Service Take out Meal type Other Price per person $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Custard
Amazing desert for a good price. You get a generous amount of custard sandwiched between perfectly baked cookies. Many choices to pick from and toppings to add!
Meh. Nothing is really spectacular there. The custard isn't creamy. Tastes like low quality ice cream. I wouldn't come again.
avatar
grace raleigh
Source: google
10
9 months ago
really good. i got the banana cream pie ice cream and my friend got the espresso oreo ice cream, they were both really yummy and the ice cream had very good stretch.
avatar
Carley Wiley
Source: google
10
4 months ago
Great selection of cookies and ice cream! Service Dine in Meal type Other Price per person $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Chocolate Chip
avatar
Alyssa Sturzl
Source: google
10
8 months ago
Absolutely delicious! Very high quality ice creams, and a large variety to choose from! Some dairy free ice creams available. I have a hard time ordering every time I go because there are so many great combinations and options. Prices are very reasonable. Staffed mostly by very friendly high schoolers.
avatar
Alan Arenz
Source: google
10
4 months ago
Had single scoop of peanut butter paradise. Very good texture and lots of added chunks of peanut butter. Should have made it into cookie sandwich but was worried about it being messy. Service Dine in Meal type Other Price per person $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes Custard
avatar
T Walker
Source: google
10
2 years ago
We always love to find the local family ice cream shop when we travel and ended up here based on their story and good reviews :) You order from a walk-up window and they have about 6 tables that you can eat at outside with umbrellas and string lights. It’s super cute! They make their own ice cream and cookies, and it’s so yummy! You can purchase ice cream in a cup, cone, or create an ice cream sandwich. We chose the sandwich route and we all enjoyed our treats! Between us, we had Mint Chip, Peanut Butter Paradise, Chocolate, & Cookie Monster ice creams as well as chocolate chip, m&m, and snickerdoodle cookies. The cookies were not hard and crunchy, but perfectly baked. If you’re in the area and need a little sweet treat, we definitely recommend stopping by!
become-owner-bg
Does this bellong to you?