Eataly NYC Flatiron Restaurant,Store,Cafe,Pizzeria in New York City

Name: Eataly NYC Flatiron
Address: 200 5th Ave, New York City, United States
Telephone: 12122292560
Rating: 4.7

Owner not registered

Eataly NYC Flatiron

Reviews

#460 From 4255 in New York City

9.4

10 Review

Ambience

9.4/10

Food

9.4/10

Interior

9.4/10

Prices

9.4/10

Service

9.4/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$$ Italian , Pizza

Establishment type

Restaurant, Store, Cafe, Pizzeria

Features

Wheelchair Accessible

Information

200 5th Ave, New York City, United States

Get direction

Website Eataly NYC Flatiron

About

In case the rain took you by surprise during the promenade around Flatiron Building, stop by this pizzeria. Eataly Nyc offers you great dishes of Italian cuisine. Don't forget to eat good anchovy, Italian pasta and pizza Margherita at this place. A lot of guests point out that waiters serve tasty Italian gelato, Italian tiramisu and chocolate cannoli here. The wine list is extensive, every visitor will find something that suits their taste. Take your chance to taste delicious macchiato, Italian espresso or hot chocolate. The high ratings of this spot wouldn't be possible without the hospitable waitstaff. There is a comfortable atmosphere and modern facade at this pizzeria. Eataly Nyc has received Google 4.5 according to the guests' opinions.

Rating

Excellent

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Nancy Dibert

Source:

3 weeks ago

We stopped by on Super Bowl Sunday to grab a few things to have for the game. As always, the selection of cheese and Italian meats was superior. We purchased several loaves of fresh bread. The focaccia was tasteless but the traditional was crusty and tasty. Both needed more salt to the dough. Disappointed in the cotton candy grapes as they were soft and lifeless. Purchased a raspberry nougat on the way out and it was absolutely incredible. Love the live music and the restaurant offerings. Hate walking through the seafood section, though, as the fishy smell gets to me. Don’t miss the fresh pasta, though!

Ognjen Mrdja

A week ago

Our favorite spot for drinking coffee and juice. Specially during sunday morning, after visiting Serbian Orthodox Cathedral right around the corner. Outdoor seating is great (during summer), and plenty of groceries, authentic italian food and drinks to choose from the shop inside. They also have nice-looking rooftop bar/restaurant. Photos are taken in August 2023.

Langston Wells

2 months ago

Don't think I've ever been to a large Italian delicacy store and restaurant. There are so many restaurants inside, so many grocery kiosks serving everything from fresh pasta to chocolate to produce to sandwiches and pannetones. It is a beautiful, must see place to walk around if you're in Flatiron. Sit down, grab a bit to eat or a cocktail at one of their many bars, so some holiday shopping or grab a take home meal kit for two and enjoy your time.

C Neon

4 months ago

Very nice marketplace dedicated to everything Italy. It has restaurants, bars, markets, butchers, fish mongers, pasta makers, and specialty vendors. A nice place to shop with neat decorations and designs. The restaurants/bars have a nice atmosphere.

Kevin L

3 months ago

When I’m in NYC I have to go here. It brings back many memories of being in Italy. Be sure to sample some olive oil. One ends up appreciating it like wine. The past is great and the pizza is some of the best in the city… which is quite something for NYC.

Jimmy Yen

This place is incredible. Couldn’t rate it in the same style as my previous reviews because it is not a singular restaurant. This is an indoor Italian marketplace and restaurant destination. Inside is a plethora of Italian food options. You can purchase food to go such as amazing looking fresh focaccia sandwiches or perhaps some fresh made pizza. Or, you can sit down at the many more fill-service type restaurants or wine bars. Or perhaps you just want to visit Eataly for some groceries and supplies to make stuff at home. They have fresh fruits, vegetables, cheese, meats, pastries, breads, coffee, chocolate, etc etc. It is reminiscent of a grocery store with some Italian flare. Soooo many options. If you don’t know what to buy, just wander a bit and pick out any of the awesome options.

Jenna North

Amazing. This is just like an Italian marketplace. Huge inside. Much more italian feel than Downtown location. Several more restaurant options at this one. The food was divine. Loved seeing the fresh made pasta. Was surprised though that employees without hairnets were allowed at the table where it was being made. I have long hair so I know how it just ends up everywhere. The girl making it had her hair covered, same for the guy. One of the servers stood at table for about 10 minutes just talking. Limited non-alcoholic or non-soda options. Bread option is well worth it for small price.

Isabella calle

Eataly Flatiron has amazing cooking pasta classes. I took my boyfriend on a date here and we had a lot of fun, we learned how to make the dough and different types of pasta, while a server brought a two-course meal, for entry we had a blue cheese, spinach, and pasta salad, and afterward a pasta with meat (I still dream off) and complementary wine. Everything is included in the course. It is an amazing date idea. I just wished they had classes later than 10:00 am. Pasta and wine at 11:00 am was a bit early. But highly recommend it.

Natalia Rodriguez

6 days ago

Wi went to Eataly Market and we eat at the little restaurant located in side the Market. The food was fantastic !! 10-10 the pasta was🤯❤️ one of the best pasta!! butter an Parmesan cheese will be back👏👏👏

Sunny Boy

I’m in love with this place. Staff is very polite and helpful. They have some amazing food items and the best in the world is the hot chocolate that’s served here. It’s simply breathtaking. It’s my go to place .