Brooklyn New York Pizza Takeaway,Pizzeria in Natick

Name: Brooklyn New York Pizza
Address: 251 W Central St, Ste 12, Natick, United States
Telephone: 15086555355
Rating: 3.8

Owner not registered

Brooklyn New York Pizza

Reviews

#63 From 118 in Natick

7.6

120 Review

Ambience

7.6/10

Food

7.6/10

Interior

7.6/10

Prices

7.6/10

Service

7.6/10

More details

Price

Establishment type

Takeaway, Pizzeria

Features

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

Information

251 W Central St, Ste 12, Natick, United States

Get direction

About

Make a change from your traditional meal and taste nicely cooked Pepperoni, parmo and pasta at this pizzeria. Brooklyn New York with takeout dishes is suitable for those visitors who like to have supper in a hurry. The nice staff welcomes people all year round. Many guests find that the service is enjoyable. According to the reviewers' opinions, prices are affordable. This place is famous for its pretty atmosphere. This spot is ranked 4 within the Google grading system.

Rating

Excellent

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Shayna Joyce

Source:

3 months ago

I saw the owners review letting everyone know they were under new management. I almost did not order because of the reviews. I was pleasantly surprised!!! I loved the pizza, had a little too much herbs on some slices but REALLY good still! Reasonable pricing, I'd order again! 10/10 Food: 5 Service: 5

Rebeca Gutierrez

6 months ago

The pastelinzhos were so good. They were medium size and had pepperoni and cheese inside. Came with a garlicky creamy sauce on the side Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Dana W

A year ago

THE BEST PIZZA. the crust is crispy and light with full flavor. You have to stop here. 3.00 per slice. I taste nyc with this pizza. I HAD TO GO BACK AND GET ANOTHER. A MUST EAT.

Christopher Barney

10 months ago

They served me the worst pizza tonight. It was disgusting and burnt. They did it on purpose because i was upset about being put on hold for 5 minutes while i heard people bickering in the backround. I've gotten great pizza here before but tonight this is what i got. I even had the chance to walk out without paying because they thought it was already paid when i walked in. Being honest though i paid anyway and even tipped. Never again. You've lost my buisness permanently. So dissapointed. I drove 20 minutes for pizza my kids won't even eat.

Vedatman Basu (Batman)

The closest you can get to "At least it isn't frozen pizza" pizza. I ordered Garlic Bread (4.99) and a Large Pizza with Pineapples and Chicken. (21). I picked up and ate the food in a timely manner with my roommate, so this review is exactly the experience most will have. Garlic Bread was basically a sub sandwich bread that was put in an oven and then perhaps maybe topped with garlic. There was no oregano, no salt, no black pepper, essentially no seasonings. Even the garlic was not strong which makes me suspect it was not fresh, but prepackaged garlic. Garlic bread is simple to make and should definitely be a top priority side for any pizza place, so I was already skeptical from my experience. The pizza was better, but not by much. Oddly dry, very bland overall. The dough could be frozen dough for all I know. It did not strike me as high quality. Price: Reasonable (4/5) Customer Service: Nothing Wrong, All Good (5/5) Quality of Food: Above (1.5/5) I was recommended this place and was disappointed; however, I will try them again as every one deserves a second chance. I also always will award an EXTRA STAR for anything that is local because we should shop local. Service Take out

Stella Price

Our company has ordered from Brooklyn New York Pizza for YEARS, and are so incredibly disappointed that Weber sold his business. On 9/8/23 we ordered for our office and literally EVERYTHING we ordered was wrong, and the Feta cheese they put on the salads was spoiled. My boss ordered an eggplant parm sandwich and received a sandwich that literally just had fried onion rings between two pieces of bread. I ordered a garden salad with Tuna, no onions and extra olives and received a Greek salad with tons of spoiled feta, NO OLIVES, and extra onions. Another employee ordered a vegetarian Greek Wrap, no onions and received a greek salad (no wrap) spoiled feta cheese and extra onions. We ended up throwing out everything concerned that the food was not edible, along with being completely wrong, and placed an order with University Pizza who always gets it right. We will not be ordering our weekly lunches from here ever again. Lastly, each time we called to advise the staff we were told they weren't the person who placed the order and we would have to speak with them. They never called back. Service Delivery Meal type Lunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 1 Service: 1

Adam Osman

9 months ago

I ordered first time this place and I’ll never order anything from this place again. I told the cashier twice “DO NOT CUT THE PIZZAS” because my son has an allergy” When I was placing an order. I got the pizza and they did cut the pizzas so I called the store and talked the cashier. She just say “ sorry about that and I can’t help you for anything “ . Service Take out Meal type Lunch Price per person $30–50 Food: 2 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Kerri Miller

2 years ago

This place is the most amazing place in the area! The food NEVER DISAPPOINTS! Restaurant is clean, staff is friendly, food is always cooked fresh and served hot!! I’ve come here quite a few times and always try something new, I’ve never been disappointed! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!

Iron Man

This is the new owner and I only had control of the place for a good week and I am trying to bring this place back alive,I understand the frustration customers went through but thst will no longer happen,I have a good control of it now and everybody working on top of there game as I am teaching them the correct way how to make good food,I plan on bring the old menu back,prices will drop down a little,food will be served completely different,I have a delivery driver that works from 11am to 4pm after that I have no delivery until I find a second driver,if you remember the old old owner that people respected and love his food well thats what I plan on doing also and as best we can,I love to serve people the right way,if they leave happy eat happy then they make my day and tells me I am doing the right thing,money is good but making people happy is even better is how I see it,so bare with me as I change alot of stuff for the better,as soon as I get the new flyer I will pass them out as soon as possible,1 more thing on 1 of the reviews somebody left a comment saying they got 3 calzone from us and all 3 was burn and that was 4 days ago that is completely false,and I know that 100% because the video they are showing the 3 burn Calzone but they 3 boxes of pizza they was in aint our box 100% I dont have that box they are showing I never ever had that box,so what I say about that good try to try to make this place look bad but you are complete wrong and if you see this comment I am writing to you to come to my shop so I can prove to you that you didn't get it...GOD BLESS everybody 🙏 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

TRUDY Almquist

5 months ago

Horrible service. Very good food, but long wait. Ordered 3 times: 2 different apps and 1 direct call. In advance, 20 mins to 2 hours. Each time was told 5 more minutes. Each time had to wait 20+ minutes; order had not been started. Food was good, but the experience was miserable. Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1